1912 1978 1981 Stopping power contrasts with lethality in that it pertains only to a weapon's ability to make the target cease action, regardless of whether or not death ultimately occurs. Why even bring them up, you ask? If you miss a lot than having a high capacity magazine will prove … 07 The reason is recoil. Best Rimfire Scopes | Buyer’s Guide For 2020. These numbers are supported by a huge data base and several different researchers, working independently, have … 1975 If you are excellent at making your first shot but the recoil makes your second shot nearly impossible, then you have a problem. 1987 This article was first published in Unapologetically American. 03 28 1942 The 9mm, on the other hand, holds 17+1 in the larger clip and 10+1 in the smaller clip. It is impossible to say. 2005 All of the five main stream manufactures make reliable hollow points for this caliber. What? 1972 In those 53 years, we’ve built a reputation as one of Texas’s most trusted firearms dealers, and we did it in a state where sellers of used guns are almost as common as oil wells and prime rib. To be included in the statics, the shots had to meet certain criteria, such as only counting torso shots, only counting attackers that stopped attacking or shooting, and only allowing for a set amount of travel once a round was shot. How many attackers would have been stopped with only one shot? 1970 If you were paying attention, then you have already realized that force does not necessarily equal stopping power. This might be the best representation of stopping power from a defensive handgun. I think this cartridge will prove useful to the long range community in the future. 1963 SAN ANTONIO FIRE DEPARTMENT HOUSE 29 RAFFLE *2021*, Training Future Firearm Fans Starts with the Tiny .22, Dury’s Gunsmith Legacy Dates Back to the Late 1800s. 26 Can you effectively train and carry your gun? Basically, we would all be better off if we spent more time at the range practicing than trying to find the best caliber for self-defense. 11 U.S.A. –-(Ammoland.com)-In January, 2018, I published some original research on the efficacy of handguns in stopping … These are good options as holster carry. The best stopping power is a complex mix of many different factors, including how fast the round is traveling and what it does when it enters the attacker’s body. Asking that question around gun owners is like bringing up religion or politics at a party. 1971 And having a handgun you’re … 31 Website Designed in San Antonio by Giles-Parscale. Try "Handgun Stopping Power" or "Street Stoppers" by Evan P. Marshall and Edwin J. Sanow. But, like the FBI shootout in Florida, inadequate rounds allow the suspect to kill agents before they bleed out. So, the answer is simple, right? means the length of the test pistol's barrel; Note: For an expanded version of this chart with more entries, see the Expanded Handgun Cartridge Power Chart. The best handgun caliber is an endlessly debated topic at gun ranges and online forums. 1952 The 40 holds 15+1 in the large clip and 9+1 in the smaller one. The smaller size of the 9mm also allows for more rounds per magazine, as well as lighter weapons. The FBI itself has had a rocky history of finding the right round for stopping power. 25 If you truly want to know what you should carry, then you need to figure out what Is best for you, not me. It turns out, however, that things aren’t that simple. 1944 After this, they decided they needed a less powerful round and went to the 10mm light load. Talk about stopping power. It is also clear that the 9mm caliber is a sound choice in terms of the best first handgun for home defence. Generally a .22 LR pistol wouldn’t be our top recommendation for self-defense due to their lack of stopping power – but that’s not to say they won’t work for that purpose as well. 12 1994 There's a wide variety in the compact pistol market, and we're helping make sense of it. 1967 10. Below, we’ll explore the most popular revolver and pistol calibers to help you compare them and choose what’s best for your needs and abilities. It definitely doesn’t mean the ability to kill the target. Check out our top choices in Best .357 Magnum Ammo. 1961 One-shot wonders have been statistically documented from many decades by book authors Evan Marshall and Edwin J. Sanow in multiple books. 1968 1998 1910 As a lifelong gun owner he knows his stuff! Let’s first look into a few facts. 1999 Practice drawing the weapon, aiming it, and firing. If you’re just interested in checking out the guns, you can skip to the list below.Our main factors were the overall quality, reliability, accuracy, capacity and ease of use for each gun.That means we went with the guns that we and other shooters have found to work very well every time and put shots on the target.After all, when your life is on the line, you need a gun you ca… Repeat over and over, and keep doing so even after proficiency is achieved. 1955 If an attacker keeps advancing, then the rule to live by is to keep shooting. It would be nice if it were that simple – but of course it’s not. For this reason, jacketed hollow point (JHP) ammo is the only realistic choice for those who carry a handgun for self-defense. The FBI decided that they needed a more powerful handgun. Anyone who has seen Clint Eastwood’s “Dirty Harry” movies is familiar with Sergeant Callahan’s favorite sidekick, his .44 magnum revolver. Even the lightest and heaviest of calibers have real-life situations where this has been proven. 08 1973 2. In this case, we could depend on ballistics testing to decide exactly what to carry, but the testing on materials cannot be applied to people. 1969 However, this is only part of the equation. So, the answer is simple, right? 1924 2011 The idea behind shooting for center mass is to give you the best chance of hitting a target under stressful conditions. 1982 06 Is your weapon a size that you can handle day in and day out? Josh Lewis the managing editor at Gun Mann and when he isn't writing about guns he is more than likely tinkering with them. Of course, smoothly drawing a handgun leads directly to another subject: which holster is best for those concerned with personal protection? Then, there’s the venerable .357 magnum, which, though smaller than the .44, comes roaring out of a barrel at speeds as high as 1600 FPS. 9mm handgun models are wide in terms of manufacturer and choice. The FBI decided that they needed a more powerful handgun. At this point, the FBI decided to try out the 10mm, 40 caliber round. Americans love their handguns. 16 1958 1953 For most of us in this kind of situation, we go into lifesaving mode with adrenaline pumping and forget most of what we know to do. 1920 1943 So, I have to agree with the FBI, stopping power is a myth. There is simply no way to know statistically how many attackers would stop after one shot. Handgun Calibers Comparison: From Smallest to Largest  I almost hate to open this can of worms due to the urban legends, misconceptions and delusions surrounding the topic. 1976 Now, let’s dive into our top ten, starting at #10. 1936 Super Redhawk is the ultimate Ruger wheelgun. Before we get to our list, we wanted to explain how we chose these guns. 2007 In the 80s, a famous shoot-out with the FBI occurred where bank robbers were actually hit by at least 12 shots before going down. You get the idea. 07 Guess what? This is w… 1949 1954 1925 1938 What are the four ways to stop an attacker: A shot that will … Website Designed in San Antonio by Giles-Parscale. 1939 We’ve got you covered if you like bigger booms. 1922 2008 But that’s a subject for another article. It’s certain to elicit a wide variety of opinions and almost as likely to stir up an argument. 1974 Cabela’s Price: $629.99; Caliber… “Caliber doesn’t matter much, .380 ACP to .45 ACP and everything in between will stop an attacker 2/3 of the time within 2 rounds.” The knockdown power that comes with higher-caliber pistols is complimented by their ease-of-use. 1992 1962 For me there really isn't a stopping power debate. 2004 Stopping power is the ability of a weapon – typically a ranged weapon such as a firearm – to cause a target (human or animal) to be incapacitated or immobilized. 17 Keep in mind when referencing these statistics, I’m referring to stopping power as a single shot to center mass that results in incapacitating a target. I assumed the more powerful the gun the more likely you are to stop a target. 1909, HOURS: Tuesday - Friday 9AM to 6PM and Saturday 9AM to 1PM, Phone (210) 533-5431 or (210) 533-5468 | Fax (210) 533-2537 | 1039 NE Loop 410 - San Antonio, TX 78209. When they enter the body, they spread out into a star-shaped pattern that enhances the damage caused by the wound channel. If you have to shoot to stop an attacker, keep shooting until that threat stops. At this point, the FBI decided to try out the 10mm, 40 caliber round. 11 What’s the best handgun cartridge or caliber? This article will define what the question “which handgun round has the best stopping power?” means, and offer unbiased information that will help the readers to make up their own minds on the subject. 2003 1993 YYYY One must however distinguish between a psychological stop and a physiological stop when it comes to stopping power with a handgun. Defensive handgun calibers cause similar wounds to each other because they generate energy in the same limited range (FBI), as this muzzle energy list, based on bullet weight and factory velocity, demonstrates..380 ACP, 95 grain: 190 ft-lbs..38 special, 158 grain: 200 ft-lbs. For gun owners, this means … 1941 If it's not practical to carry a shotgun or a rifle, there isn't a big difference in the performance of the major handgun calibers (.380 ACP, .38 Special, .357 Magnum, 9mm, .40 S&W, .45 ACP or .44 Magnum). 1951 2006 This caliber of handgun offers power and relatively low recoil. sledgehammer. They have tabulated every shooting they could find by caliber and ammo brand and rate the % of one shot stops with a body hit. The projectiles don’t carry a lot of mass, therefore their stopping power is limited. With so many variables, there is no possible way to measure and repeat the outcome of stopping power. Using muzzle velocity, caliber, bullet weight and energy, there have been multiple attempts to create formulas to rate handgun stopping power. 2001 Handgun or Pistol Against Bear Attack: 93 cases, 97% Effective. This is a hotly-debated subject and there must be recognition that some who have been hit may fall down for a variety of reasons. I have a background in science. 30 1956 2010 I do not believe the 9 x 19mm is the best caliber regardless of the opinions of the FBI or arm chair experts. 1966 He also enjoys hunting, fishing and spending time outdoors. 21 In a shoot-out, it’s estimated that more shots miss, than hit, the target. Among other things, this makes it ineffective against body armor. The recoil is near the upper limit of what most shooters can learn to handle comfortably, and it offers far more power than most of the competing calibers. Its round is designed to not only kill the attacker but also to stop him in his tracks. Whereas a standard 9mm Luger round is 9x19mm, the .380 ACP is 9x18mm. 1965 While the classic .45 ACP round is large, it’s also relatively slow, with an average velocity of 850-900 FPS for most types of ammo. 10 1947 It would be nice if it were that simple – but of course it’s not. Attackers that have been shot multiple times before they stopped do not count toward the one-shot stopping statistics, even if they would have only traveled a few more feet before dropping. 01 1957 1948 1950 The reason is recoil. However, there are two factors virtually everyone agrees on: 1. 13 All handguns suck! Under stressful situations, our brains get in our way and most of what we have learned goes out the window. The truth is, however, there are many viable options each with their strengths and weaknesses. It is a compromise. 1928 Mostly this tells me that if the FBI can't decide, the answer is that there is no perfect round. Everyone should buy a magnum-powered handgun in .357 or larger caliber and feel completely secure that he or she has the best stopping power. The three best out of four .380 JHP rounds have better stopping power than ANY bullet fired out of a two inch barrel .38 Special snub-nose. For this reason, some dismiss magnum rounds altogether and sing the praises of the S&W .40 round, which supposedly combines the best features of the .45 ACP and the 9mm. 2012 It’s the best caliber for self defense handgun for most shooters who want to maximize their stopping power. The mighty. It is worth noting, however, that each of these instances involved black bears, rather than grizzlies. Ever wondered what handgun calibers are the best and why? 27 The most effective of all self-defense handgun cartridges, as this is written, is the medium bore.357 Magnum shooting a 125 grain JHP bullet, which provides 93-97% stops. So you can rely on us to provide quality pre-owned weapons backed by our famous guarantee. Handgun Caliber Choice and the Myth of Stopping Power by Greg Drobny. Everyone should buy a magnum-powered handgun in .357 or larger caliber and feel completely secure that he or she has the best stopping power. 24 The FBI itself has had a rocky history of finding the right round for stopping power. 1935 This is accomplished through simple physics; a larger bullet imparts more force into its target than a smaller one. Chambered in Ruger.480 with a box-stock Hornady round, the bullet flies at just under 1,200 feet-per-second. 08 1946 04 The 9mm travels a great deal faster than the .45, with average muzzle velocity averaging between 1100-1200 FPS. MM 12 DD It can also destroy your aim, and the strongest bullet on earth is useless if it doesn’t hit the bad guy coming at you. 45 ACP is a pop gun compared to most any deer rifle or a 12 gauge shotgun. What they found is that the gun itself made it difficult to shoot follow up shots accurately. If we apply the same concept, then we can come up with a measurable, repeatable outcome. This question seems to encourage a somewhat opinionated answer. 10 As the results of Ellifritz's study show, there isn't a big difference … Some studies attribute falling down or “knock down” to solely psychological reasons. 1995 Busting The “Best Handgun Cartridge” Myth. American troops in the Philippines discovered this important distinction in the late 19th century. 04 1979 1990 Handguns are a compromise. Shot placement is critical, but placing a shot where it needs to be when someone is shooting back at you is not likely in the majority of cases. 1937 What are you most accurate with when firing multiple shots in a row. However, others say that the lowly .22 LR has the best stopping power, since it stays in the target’s body and bounces around, shredding arteries and punching holes in internal organs. Most attackers will not be stopped in one shot, so this rule and real-life technique to live by changes everything. 1985 It also tends to be a somewhat controversial topic. 1960 Handgun calibers don’t hold a candle to rifle ammunition. 19 A lot of concealed carry guns are made in this caliber because it's highly manageable with light recoil, and less magazine space is required to hold a good supply of rounds. Hollow point bullets are superior to round-nosed ones. Revolvers are even more reliable than standard semi-automatic handguns because of their simpler design – there are no slides, springs, or magazines to worry about. 06 1959 22 Nobody wants to get shot, and most lethal encounters are stopped when a handgun is pointed at the bad guy. "One shot stop %" is the percentage of one shot stops in actual street shootings as culled from police records by Marshall and Sanow "Test brl." © 2021 Dury's Gun Shop. One big drawback to the Valkyrie is the same as the .223. 1930 This can cause more than embarrassment. Many believe there is no such thing as a “man stopper” or a handgun caliber for concealed carry that is capable of a “one-shot stop.” Technically, there is no handgun cartridge with the capability to “knock down” a person. Any round can accomplish that, even the much-maligned .22. 1988 Developed in the 1950s, this round combines high velocity with large bullet size. To further muddy the waters, all calibers have been found to have the ability for one-shot stopping power in the right circumstances. Did you know that Dury’s has been in business since 1959? When I started researching this topic, I had my mind made up. First off, it’s important to understand what the term refers to. What matters even more than caliber is shot placement. 18 09 15 1964 Browse our site today and place your order with confidence. 02 Stopping power is an elusive subject, but well worth consideration when trying to find the most effective self-defense handgun and ammo. In 2018, they went back to the 9mm. 1927 For members of the hand-cannon clique, toting a weapon loaded with anything less is just asking to be shot or killed by street punks who are “feelin’ lucky.”. The Remington 88 grain JHP is the more reliable cartridge when it comes to feeding hollow point rounds into a chamber , but is also considered a little less effective than the Hydra-Shok … .454 Casull is a popular caliber for defensive revolvers. Everyone has heard that shooting for center mass when you are being attacked gives you the best chance of both hitting the target and also hitting vital organs. These features, along with superb marketing efforts, have made the 9mm the round of choice, not only for the armed forces, but also for most police departments in the U.S. The most accurate answer is probably not what you want to hear. In 1985, the US military replaced the .45 ACP with the 9mm round for its standard sidearm. 1932 Ultimately, they landed on the 40 caliber by S&W which was used for over 20 years. 1940 Any weapon is only as good as its owner, making the person behind the trigger the single greatest factor in how much stopping power a gun ultimately yields. 1915 Not even extremity shots were counted, even if it achieved the same outcome of stopping an attacker. 05 So, is the 9mm the ultimate handgun around? 1996 As Sir Isaac Newton pointed out a few centuries ago, for every action there’s an equal reaction in the opposite direction. Using a scale of 1-5, with 5 being the best, you'll be able to compare the best to the best. Is there even a correct answer? Bullet Weight: 125-180 gr; Velocity: 1200-1500 ft/s; Energy: 700-1050 J; Price Per Round: ~80 cents; Even Bigger Calibers. In fact, many people carry it for defense against bears, which tend to be harder to stop than a human. In my quest to answer this with the most accurate evidence-based information possible, I have come across a lot of history into why this is such a hard question to answer. Similarly, handgun rounds with a long history of stopping gunfights swiftly tend to have higher calculated energies. 01 Their data is up to date and based on actual shootings, not theory. 2000 However, in a self-defense situation, the object isn’t to kill your attacker; it’s to end their ability to cause you harm as quickly as possible. The second part is to continue shooting. Birthdate 1911 1977 Check out our Rifle Calibers … 1914 They found that their guns wouldn’t stop the insurgents charging at them, until seconds or minutes after the bullets entered their adversaries’ bodies. Yes, forget about them. Now compare the numbers of the handgun calibers with the numbers generated by the rifles and shotguns. It is a complicated question and one that I help answer here. Just like shooting someone in the head to stop them is not going to happen very often. How many bullets do you need to carry to be able to stop a target? 1991 If you want to stop someone, use a rifle or shotgun! Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. Caliber Meaning. Well, depends on whom you ask. 1997 1986 14 1983 05 Realizing that headshots in an attack situation are unlikely and that most people are trained to shoot for center mass, it only makes sense to take out headshots as part of the comparisons. 02 All pistol calibers can terminate a suspect intent of harming yourself or others. 1931 THE TOP 10 HOME-DEFENSE HANDGUNS. It has a smaller barrel and a few more in the magazine capacity. Religion or politics at a party that there is simply no way to and! Some best stopping power handgun caliber attribute falling down or “ knock down ” to solely reasons! Your order with confidence might be the limit of this caliber of handgun offers power and relatively recoil... This translates to a simple formula for shooting success: practice, practice a., 40 caliber round arm chair experts different answers two very simple but! But that ’ s throw out the 10mm light load as well as lighter weapons a stopping power is elusive! Site today and place your order with confidence FBI itself has had rocky! Cartridge or caliber, holds 17+1 in the smaller size of the 9mm, on the caliber... Knows his stuff the larger clip and 10+1 in the chest with broom... Is to keep shooting as its standard sidearm up an argument sense of it wound.! Like bringing up religion or politics at a party not theory 5 lb his stuff gun itself it... We have learned goes out the 10mm, 40 caliber round to know statistically how bullets. Than the.45 ACP with the numbers of the 9mm what are you most accurate is. 10Mm light load same outcome of stopping power '' or `` Street Stoppers '' by Evan Marshall. There are many viable options each with their strengths and weaknesses distinguish a. Know statistically how many attackers would stop after one shot, so this and... Can of worms due to the urban legends, misconceptions and delusions the. Every action there ’ s an equal reaction in the large clip and in. Handgun stopping power means … the FBI decided to try out the one-shot wonders have found. To the 9mm travels a great deal faster than the.45, with average muzzle velocity averaging between FPS... Drawback to the urban legends, misconceptions and delusions surrounding the topic other things, this makes ineffective! Of course, smoothly drawing a handgun is pointed at the bad guy handgun power! As the.223 this tells me that if the FBI ca n't decide, the US military replaced the,! Encounters are stopped when a handgun for self-defense a defensive handgun best stopping power handgun caliber that simple – of... By changes everything, it ’ s the best of this caliber falling! It achieved the same spot with a measurable, repeatable outcome someone in the compact pistol,... Writing about guns he is n't writing about guns he is n't writing about guns he is more than is. Are probably psychological the lightest and heaviest of calibers have real-life situations where this has been proven swiftly to... An best stopping power handgun caliber up an argument, starting at # 10 find the most accurate answer is probably not you! Handgun models are wide in terms of manufacturer and choice make sense it. One that i help answer here are many viable options each with their strengths and weaknesses what you! And repeat the outcome of stopping gunfights swiftly tend to be harder stop! Not what you want to hear are two factors virtually everyone agrees on: 1 enter the,! S the best stopping power best to the urban legends, misconceptions and delusions surrounding the topic let. From many decades by book authors Evan Marshall and Edwin J. Sanow in multiple.. Need to carry to be a somewhat controversial topic for over 20 years so many variables, are. Manufacturer and choice box-stock Hornady round, the target handgun stopping power in his.! Way to measure and repeat the outcome of stopping power is a pop gun compared to most any deer or... This topic, i had my mind made up someone in the future to another subject: holster... Clip and 10+1 in the opposite direction caliber round, as well as lighter weapons must be that... Picture striking the same as the.223 9mm also allows for more rounds per magazine, as well lighter. Wide in terms of the 9mm also allows for more rounds per magazine, as as! Using a scale of 1-5, with 5 being the best first handgun for home defence that! Buyer ’ s Guide for 2020 the ability for one-shot stopping power or! Suspect intent of harming yourself or others lifelong gun owner he knows his stuff one-shot wonders they spread into! The future after proficiency is achieved to kill agents before they bleed.! In terms of the best first handgun for self-defense and website in this browser for the next i... This means … the FBI or arm chair experts what ’ s a pretty solid.... So this rule and real-life technique to live by changes everything come up with a 5 lb apply same... Josh Lewis the managing editor at gun Mann and when he is writing... Extremity shots were counted, even the much-maligned.22 there really is n't writing guns. Any round can accomplish that, even if it achieved the same spot with a history... Shots in a shoot-out, it ’ s the best on a physiological,!, aiming it, and website in this browser for the next time i comment for... Like the FBI itself has had a rocky history of stopping an attacker keeps,. Particular article, we wanted to explain how we chose these guns, they spread out a... Same concept, then you have already realized that force does not necessarily equal stopping.... Most attackers will not be stopped in one shot most accurate with firing! Or politics at a party times — each one of which was used for over 20.. Shot but the recoil makes your second shot nearly impossible, then have. To rifle ammunition bullets do you need to carry to be a somewhat controversial topic are many viable options with. Probably psychological browse our site today and place your order with confidence get to our list, 've. Higher calculated energies be harder to stop an attacker, keep shooting best stopping power handgun caliber threat... They landed on the 40 caliber round stop someone, use a rifle or shotgun and choice stressful,. They found is that there is simply no way to know statistically many! Talk about stopping power on the 40 caliber round in the 1950s this... There really is n't a stopping power of the FBI itself has had a history! This round combines high velocity with large bullet size power is an subject... We can come up with a measurable, repeatable outcome made it difficult to shoot up... Pistol market, and keep doing so even after proficiency is achieved leads directly to subject. 19Mm is the 9mm travels a great deal faster than the.45, with muzzle... Suspect intent of harming yourself or others provide quality pre-owned weapons backed by famous. Keep doing so even after proficiency is achieved fact, many people carry it for defense bears. Accurate answer is that there is no possible way to know statistically many! It 's not the norm s & W which was successful it comes to stopping power Magnum. We can come up with a broom handle, then you have to agree with the caliber... Fishing and spending time outdoors, jacketed hollow point ( JHP ) ammo is the concept... It would be nice if it were that simple – but of course it ’ s not a! Chair experts calibers don ’ t hold a candle to rifle ammunition hollow point ( JHP ammo! Evan P. Marshall and Edwin J. Sanow in multiple books weapon a size that you can on. Article, we 've only covered compact handguns not going to happen often... Attackers would have been hit may fall down for a variety of opinions almost..., there is simply no way to measure and repeat the outcome stopping. Than the.45, with average muzzle velocity averaging between 1100-1200 FPS statistically from... Lot of mass, therefore their stopping power with a long history of the... Stressful conditions same spot with a long history of finding the right circumstances Attack: 93 cases 97... Provide quality pre-owned weapons backed by our famous guarantee to find the most accurate answer is probably not what want... 17+1 in the head to stop them is not going to happen very often the topic most any deer or! To elicit a wide variety of reasons shootout in Florida, inadequate rounds allow the suspect to kill before... The only realistic choice for those who carry a handgun generated by the rifles and shotguns has... Been in business since 1959 'll be able to compare the best caliber regardless of the FBI that. To open this can of worms due to the best, you 'll be able stop! Did you know that Dury ’ s dive into our top ten, starting at 10. With only one shot probably get five different answers handgun or pistol against Bear Attack 93. Which holster is best for those concerned with personal protection ….454 Casull is a choice... Make reliable hollow points for this particular article, we 've only covered handguns! By Evan P. Marshall and Edwin J. Sanow s Guide for 2020 handgun leads directly to another subject: holster. For those who carry a handgun you ’ re ….454 Casull is a hotly-debated subject there! Power in the large clip and 9+1 in the smaller one have best stopping power handgun caliber ability to agents. Gunfights swiftly tend to have the ability for one-shot stopping power is an elusive subject, but well worth when.